header logo

Applying the fundamental account theory - more complications

While it is technically true that there is some equity in almost every material possession, people who think properly and conservatively about money do not regard the equity in their possessions as contributors to their net worth except in the case of real estate. If you own a home, whatever equity you have in the home is part of your net worth.

Buying a home with a mortgage means you have acquired an asset (the house) which raises your net worth by X. The amount put down and the liability (the loan) lower your net worth by X so the net effect is that buying the large asset does not change your net worth at all, it just changes your cash flow situation. This means that when you make mortgage payments some of it goes to interest (which is an expense that lowers your net worth) and some of it goes to principal (which is just moving assets around between net worth containers, yellow arrows). Whatever interest you pay on your mortgage is a tax-deductible expense, so it is worth tracking. Consider the following transactions:

Date Description Value From To
2015-06-01 Borrowed money for home loan $250,000 mortgage loan home
2015-06-01 Mortgage principle payment $100 checking account mortgage loan
2015-06-01 Mortgage interest payment $900 checking account housing expense
2015-07-01 Mortgage principle payment $120 checking account mortgage loan
2015-07-01 Mortgage interest payment $880 checking account housing expense
2015-08-01 Mortgage principle payment $140 checking account mortgage loan
2015-08-01 Mortgage interest payment $860 checking account housing expense
2015-09-01 Mortgage principle payment $160 checking account mortgage loan
2015-09-01 Mortgage interest payment $840 checking account housing expense
2015-10-01 Mortgage principle payment $180 checking account mortgage loan
2015-10-01 Mortgage interest payment $820 checking account housing expense
2015-11-01 Mortgage principle payment $200 checking account mortgage loan
2015-11-01 Mortgage interest payment $800 checking account housing expense

The total in the "home" wealth container account is the amount paid into equity which is important for tax purposes when the home is sold. The total "housing expense" spending category will contain all the interest payments which are important for claiming tax deductions.

Both the mortgage loan and home equity are wealth containers that contribute to your net worth.

Mortgage Loan
2015-06-01 Borrowed money for home loan -$250,000
2015-06-01 Mortgage principle payment $100
2015-07-01 Mortgage principle payment $120
2015-08-01 Mortgage principle payment $140
2015-09-01 Mortgage principle payment $160
2015-10-01 Mortgage principle payment $180
2015-11-01 Mortgage principle payment $200
Total-$249,100
Home Equity
2015-06-01 Borrowed money for home loan $250,000
Total$250,000
Net worth in home$900

"Housing expenses" is a spending category and does not contribute to your net worth.

Housing expense
2015-06-01 Mortgage interest payment $100
2015-07-01 Mortgage interest payment $120
2015-08-01 Mortgage interest payment $140
2015-09-01 Mortgage interest payment $160
2015-10-01 Mortgage interest payment $180
2015-11-01 Mortgage interest payment $200
Total$5100
Follow @domesticengine7

© MC Byington